Did Rod Rosenstein Pressure Mueller to Enter the Plea Deal with Paul Manafort?

Transcript

1 DID ROD ROSENSTEIN PRESSURE MUELLER TO ENTER THE PLEA DEAL WITH PAUL MANAFORT? Bill Barr’s admission the other day that he and Rod Rosenstein started talking about how to deny that Trump obstructed justice on March 5, long before even getting the Mueller Report, has raised real questions about whether the two men pushed Mueller to finish his investigation (even though the Mystery Appellant and Andrew Miller subpoenas were still pending). But I’ve started wondering whether Rosenstein — the guy who promised Trump he’d “ land the plane ” while he was trying to keep his job — hasn’t been pressuring Mueller to finish up even longer than that. At the beginning of Manafort’s breach hearing , Andrew Weissmann described how this plea deal was different from most normal plea deals. There were two points that I wanted to make to the Court. There are a number of subparts to them. But, the first point has to do with sort of the context in which we operated at the time that we entered into the agreement. As the Court will recall, the agreement was entered into just shortly before the trial was to commence before this Court, and it was after three proffer sessions. And then, of course, there were many debriefings after that. And a couple things about that timing that are relevant. One, at the end of the third proffer session, before entering into the agreement, we had made clear to the defense that we were willing to go forward. But, that given the limited

2 opportunity, and yet the need to make a decision because of the eminent [sic] trial, we wanted to make clear to the defense that, of course, we were going in with good faith. But we could not say at that point that we either could say the defendant was being truthful or that the defendant was going to be able to meet the substantial assistance prong. In other words, two parts of the agreement. Of course, I think everyone was hopeful that all of that would be met. But we wanted to make it clear to the defense that they weren’t being misled in any way as to what we were thinking. And the second component of that is, I think, something unusual — there were two factors that were unusual in this case compared to, I think, the cases that all of us at this table have had in the past. One was, there’s enormous interest in what I will call — for lack of a better term — the intelligence that could be gathered from having a cooperating witness in this particular investigation. And that would account for the Government agreeing to have Mr. Manafort cooperate, even though it was after a trial. Because that’s certainly an — not — not — it’s not that that never happens, but it’s more atypical. By the same token, there was an unusual factor — the second unusual factor, which was [redacted] the normal motives and incentives that are built into a cooperation agreement. To sum up, it was unusual because: They didn’t do all the vetting they would normally do before entering into a

3 plea deal, There was a big push to avoid the September 2018 trial They entered a plea deal when they weren’t sure about Manafort’s reliability in part to get intelligence, not prosecutorial information Another factor, which is redacted, which by context is likely to be Trump’s floating of a pardon In other words, there was great pressure to enter into this plea deal that led them not to do the vetting they would normally have. We already know from the breach determination that Manafort said some things during his proffers that led prosecutors to give him the plea deal, but about which he promptly changed his story. Those subjects include, at a minimum, the degree to which his business associate Konstantin Kilimnik had formally entered into a conspiracy with him, how his kickback system worked, and the criminality of some Trump associate who tried something in August 2016 to save Trump’s campaign. But the breach determination also revealed that always lying about his ongoing Manafort was discussions with Kilimnik about a “peace” deal. Over the course of his “cooperation,” he came to admit some parts of it after being shown evidence, but he never offered up those details. That means that when Mueller entered into that plea deal, they knew Manafort was lying to them, at least about the Ukrainian “peace” deals and his coordination with Kilimnik. But the Mueller Report also reveals were also

4 two details Manafort told them during his proffers that the prosecutors didn’t believe. Manafort told prosecutors that he could not recall “anyone informing candidate Trump of the [June 9] meeting, including Trump Jr;” prosecutors already had other testimony suggesting this was false, and the day after Manafort told them this on September 11, 2018 (and before they actually finalized the deal), Michael Cohen described Don Jr discussing a meeting secretly with Trump in this time period. That same day, Manafort also told prosecutors, “that he did not believe Kilimnik was working as a Russian ‘spy,'” even though several other Kilimnik colleagues, including Rick Gates, had told Mueller’s team he was. So Mueller knew Manafort was lying, and yet still gave him a plea deal, which had the effect of averting a trial that would have been a key focus of press attention during the midterm elections. I laid out how Manafort’s failed plea ended up providing cover during the election season in this post . Rudy Giuliani, remember, repeatedly said that Mueller would have to wrap up the entire investigation before DOJ’s 90 day election season. I know there are a lot of DOJ beat reporters trying to chase down whether Barr told Mueller he had to finish up as soon as he got cleared to oversee the investigation in March. But I wonder whether Rosenstein wasn’t already pressuring Mueller to finish, going back to August. If he was, that would change the import of Trump’s tactic to avoid testifying — first stalling through the election, and then refusing any real cooperation — significantly. It would also change the import of the fact that prosecutors still claim that the investigation into Manafort is ongoing. As I disclosed last July, I provided information to the FBI on issues related to the Mueller investigation, so I’m going to include

5 disclosure statements on Mueller investigation posts from here on out. I will include the disclosure whether or not the stuff I shared with the FBI pertains to the subject of the post.

Related documents

911 Call Logs   2017 Updated

911 Call Logs 2017 Updated

Fire and EMS 24 Hour Call Report 2019-04-10 through 2019-05-09 Address Problem City Call Date Call Time Incident Number 2019-05-09 < 100 block of HOSPITAL DR 5/9/2019 12:34:40 AM 37A02 Level I Transfe...

More info »
htkbook

htkbook

The HTK Book Steve Young Gunnar Evermann Dan Kershaw Gareth Moore Julian Odell Dave Ollason Dan Povey Valtcho Valtchev Phil Woodland The HTK Book (for HTK Version 3.2) c © COPYRIGHT 1995-1999 Microsof...

More info »
Vital Statistics Reference Guidance, Number 2, May, 2019

Vital Statistics Reference Guidance, Number 2, May, 2019

Vital Statistics Reporting Guidance ■ Report No. 2 May 2019 A Reference Guide for Completing the Death Certificate for Drug Toxicity Deaths By following the instructions provided in this Reference Gui...

More info »
2017 1011 EEB Revisions to RP 6.7 Records of the University RP 5.10 FERPA  (00019133.DOC;1)

2017 1011 EEB Revisions to RP 6.7 Records of the University RP 5.10 FERPA (00019133.DOC;1)

University of Nebraska Board of Regents Policies Contains Amendments through March 29, 2019

More info »
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer, and HIV Affected Intimate Partner Violence in 2015

Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer, and HIV Affected Intimate Partner Violence in 2015

Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer, and HIV-Affected Intimate Partner Violence in 2015 A report from the National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs 2016 Release Edition

More info »
May 01 2019

May 01 2019

For Date: 05/01/2019 - Wednesday Call Time Call Reason Action Number - 0054 EXTRA PATROL No Problems Noted/Nothing New 16129 19 Location/Address: MILTON RD Post: DWARD5 - Arvd - 01:05:58 00:55:01 Clrd...

More info »
avianflu

avianflu

FOR STATE USE ONLY # Novel Influenza A such as H5N1 confirmed  COUNTY ___/___/___ case report presumptive  suspect  ___/___/___ interstate CASE IDENTIFICATION (check all that apply) SOURCES OF REPO...

More info »
Duodenoscope Investigation FINAL Report

Duodenoscope Investigation FINAL Report

United States Senate ENSIONS EALTH E DUCATION , L ABOR , H P , C OMMITTEE AND Patty Murray, Ranking Member Preventable Tragedies : Superbugs and How Ineffective Monitoring of Medical Device Safety Fai...

More info »
credit profile report

credit profile report

Product sheet Credit Profile Report Precise data. Unsurpassed file coverage. You can’t make the best decisions if you don’t have the best information. That’s where we come in. With Experian’s Credit P...

More info »
Geology of St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands

Geology of St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands

3:33 PM P1631cover.qxd Page 1 5/16/03 D U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey irgin Islands Geology of St. John, U.S. V Rankin—GEOLOGY U.S. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY PROFESSIONAL P APER 1631 ...

More info »
Uranium 2014: Resources, Production and Demand

Uranium 2014: Resources, Production and Demand

A Joint Report by the OECD Nuclear Energy Agency and the International Atomic Energy Agency Uranium 2014: Resources, Production and Demand U ranium 2014: Resources, Production and Demand N E A

More info »
Alcoholics Anonymous Second Edition

Alcoholics Anonymous Second Edition

ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS The Story of How Many Thousa Men and Women nds of Have Recovered fr om Alcohol ism NEW AND REV ISE D EDIT ION ALCOHOL ICS ANONYMOUS WORL D SERVICE S, I NC. NEW YOR K CITY 1955

More info »
DataWindow

DataWindow

D/T Arrested D/T Arrested D/T Arrested D/T Arrested Page 1 of 19 CN# CN# CN# CN# 19005408 04/30/2019 16:15 17023727 04/30/2019 11:00 19089030 05/01/2019 00:20 19089030 05/01/2019 00:20 19008292 04/30/...

More info »
07 5123 06 zigbee cluster library specification

07 5123 06 zigbee cluster library specification

ZigBee Cluster Library – 075123 Document ZigBee Cluster Library Specification Revision 6 Draft Version 1.0 - 0125 Chapter Document: 14 5123 - 07 ZigBee Document: 06 - ZigBee Document 07 - 5123 201 4 J...

More info »
ayout 1

ayout 1

0465039146-FM:FM 12/5/06 12:25 AM Page i C O D E

More info »
AI Now Report 2018   Published Version   Locked   Google Docs

AI Now Report 2018 Published Version Locked Google Docs

t 2018 AI Now Repor er , AI Now Institute, New Y ork Univ ersity , Google Open Resear ch Mer edith Whittak awfor , AI Now Institute, New Y ork Univ ersity , Micr osoft Resear ch d Kate Cr , AI Now Ins...

More info »
JO 7400.11C   Airspace Designations and Reporting Points

JO 7400.11C Airspace Designations and Reporting Points

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION ORDER FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 7400.11C JO Air Traffic Organization Policy August 13, 2018 SUBJ: Airspace Designations and Reporting Points . This O rder, publ...

More info »
DataWindow

DataWindow

D/T Arrested 05/02/2019 11:35 D/T Arrested D/T Arrested D/T Arrested Page 1 of 19 CN# CN# CN# CN# 19004620 05/03/2019 02:42 19090593 05/02/2019 22:45 19DOC1563 16002019 05/02/2019 08:25 :00 05/03/2019...

More info »
fast18 failSlowHw

fast18 failSlowHw

Fail-Slow at Scale: Evidence of Hardware Performance Faults in Large Production Systems 1 2 2 1 , Casey Golliher Haryadi S. Gunawi , , Russell Sears , Riza O. Suminto 4 4 5 3 , Xing Lin , , Weiguang S...

More info »
Chapter 3 - More About Alcoholism - (pp. 30-43)

Chapter 3 - More About Alcoholism - (pp. 30-43)

Chapter 3 MORE ABOUT ALCOHOLISM have been unwilling to admit we ost of us M were real alcoholics. No person likes to think he is bodily and mentally different from his fellows. Ther efore, it is not s...

More info »